Published: June 28, 2022 By

Banner image: Physicist Jun Ye gives U.S. Rep. Joe Neguse a tour of his lab at JILA on the CU Boulder campus. (Credit: Glenn Asakawa/CU Boulder)

In the 17th Century, a Dutch merchant named Antony van Leeuwenhoek began experimenting with making new microscope lenses and, in the process, plunged humanity into a new world—this one teeming with previously-undiscovered life, from small bacteria to single-celled algae and more.

More than 400 years later, scientists are in the midst of an equally-important revolution. They’re diving into a previously-hidden realm—far wilder than anything van Leeuwenhoek, known as the “father of microbiology,” could have imagined. Some researchers, like physicists Margaret Murnane and Henry Kapteyn, are exploring this world of even tinier things with microscopes that are many times more precise than the Dutch scientist’s. Others, like Jun Ye, are using lasers to cool clouds of atoms to just a millionth of a degree above absolute zero with the goal of collecting better measurements of natural phenomena. 

“To borrow a phrase, we’re going where no one has gone before,” said quantum physicist Ye, a fellow at JILA, a joint research institute between CU Boulder and the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). 

 Continue reading...

 

A quantum dictionary

Noah Finkelstein

Noah Finkelstein is a professor of physics at CU Boulder and a member of the Physics Education Research group. Here, he explains some of the most important, and strangest, concepts in quantum physics.

Fundamental units (packets, or “quanta”) of light. Proposed by Einstein, building on the insights of Max Planck, these are the smallest amounts of energy that light or any electromagnetic radiation, including radio waves, X-rays and more, can have. This representation of light as photons captures the particle-like behavior of light that had been considered purely wave-like previously. Notably, a beam of light is made up of many, many photons, just like a dollar is made up of many pennies.

In very special conditions two (or more) quantum objects, such as photons or atoms, can share properties even if separated by great distances. Measuring the properties of one determines the others’ state instantaneously. This is so foreign to our everyday lives that Einstein referred to this as “spooky action at a distance.”

In quantum mechanics, the state of a system (an object or collection of objects) can take on multiple values at one time. That is, until a particular property, like the energy state of a system, is measured, it can be in multiple states at once. These states can be manipulated in collection (simultaneously) rather than one-by-one, which gives rise to the power of quantum supercomputing.  

Setting the fundamental limits of a system that can be known, as determined by specific pairs of quantities, such as position and momentum, or energy and time. The more precisely one quantity is known (say, position), the greater the uncertainty of the other other quantity (momentum). Both properties of the system cannot be precisely known or measured at the same time. This gives rise to the old joke: When a speeder is caught by a police officer, they reply to the question of “do you know how fast you were going?” with “it is unknowable, but I know precisely where I am.”

Check out PhET Interactive Simulations to learn more about quantum physics.

Continued from above:

Murnane, Kapteyn and Ye are among a growing number of Colorado researchers dedicating their careers to the exploration of quantum physics, the study of the universe at its smallest scales. In this microscopic world, electrons can exist in several places at the same time. Particles tunnel through solid matter and hop out the other side, while atoms tick like tiny pendulums quadrillions of times per second.

Just as microscopes paved the way for antibiotics and modern medicine, better control of the quantum world could revolutionize everything from timekeeping and medical imaging to space travel and next-generation electronic and energy devices. And both its birth and growth are rooted in Colorado. 

In the Centennial State, this revolution emerged from the work of countless scientists, including four Nobel Prize laureates (see “Interactive timeline”) working over decades. Today, CU researchers and their collaborators continue to lay the groundwork, with research centers like STROBE and Quantum Systems through Entangled Science and Engineering (Q-SEnSE). These efforts are helping to transform the state into a new Silicon Valley, only this time, a Quantum Valley.

“It’s amazing to see all these companies building off of Nobel Prize-winning research,” said Philip Makotyn, executive director of the CUbit Quantum Initiative, which connects quantum researchers and companies in Colorado. “It’s just a rich ecosystem that doesn't exist anywhere else.”

Quantum, quantum everywhere

Makotyn, who earned his doctorate in physics from CU Boulder, has a photo that he likes to show—of Boulder in the 1920s, with horse-drawn carriages trundling down the then-dirt Pearl Street. 

“In the early 1900s, some physicists said—it was a little tongue-in-cheek—that they had figured out everything there was to know about the universe,” Makotyn said. “And the only pursuit left was to make a better steam engine or horseless carriage. They had no idea the scale of the quantum mechanical revolution about to fundamentally change the world.”  

The field was pioneered by researchers like Niels Bohr, whose ideas about the structure of atoms still pop up in every high school chemistry textbook; Maria Goeppert Mayer, who predicted how atoms absorb intense laser light; and Werner Heisenberg, whose uncertainty principle states, for example, that you can accurately measure the location of a particle or its velocity but not both at the same time. Scientists and engineers, in turn, built off those insights to design devices like transistors, semiconductors and lasers—which take advantage of the quantum mechanical nature of electrons and light waves to run all modern electronics and the internet.

If you looked at a photo of Pearl Street today, in other words, everything you saw would “scream quantum mechanics,” Makotyn said.

And more innovation is coming: Imagine a future in which you commute to work using a navigation app that keeps running, even when you duck into a subway station out of range of GPS; where microscopes can record real-time videos from deep inside living cells or nanodevices; and where new supercomputers can discover and test novel drugs in record time.

This new burst of quantum research embraces the strangest properties of physics. They include entanglement, a kind of “spooky” connection between particles or atoms; and superposition, or objects existing in multiple states at the same time (see “A Quantum Dictionary”). Scientists are also striving to manipulate quantum systems to enable new microscopes or to bring quantum effects to the realm of larger things—enabling properties they didn’t know were possible.

These concepts aren’t always easy to grasp, said theoretical physicist Ana Maria Rey. Ultimately, they’re not like any of the “classical” physics humans encounter during our day-to-day lives. 

“The quantum realm is extremely rich and complex, and fully understanding it can be as complicated as navigating the sea without a compass,” said Rey, a NIST and JILA fellow. 

Some tech companies, however, are beginning to explore those waters, including several businesses founded by CU Boulder researchers. They include ColdQuanta, Vescent Photonics, LongPath Technologies, FieldLine, Inc.Atom Computing, Stable Laser Systems and KM Labs. In all, such startups employ more than 1,000 people in the state and generate an estimated economic impact of around $400 million.

Graphic of an atomic clock

Artist's depiction of an atomic clock. (Credit: Steven Burrows/JILA)

Quantum for sensing our world

Researchers at CU Boulder and LongPath Technologies are using quantum sensors to detect methane leaks from oil and gas sites. (Credit: CU Boulder)

That new quantum revolution began, in many ways, with a clock—not a wristwatch or a grandfather clock, but a device that can do a lot more with the help of atoms.

Today, scientists at JILA and NIST are developing some of the world’s most precise and accurate atomic clocks. They build off decades of work by Nobel laureates Jan Hall, Dave Wineland and Eric Cornell and Carl Wieman.

First, researchers collect clouds of atoms and chill them down, then trap those atoms in an “artificial crystal” made of laser light. Next, they hit the atoms with yet another laser. Like pushing a pendulum, that laser beam starts the atoms “ticking,” causing them to oscillate between energy levels at a rate of quadrillions of times per second.

Child wears helmet made up of dozens of sensors

Child wears a helmet made up of more than 100 OPM sensors. (Credit: FieldLine)

These clocks are also incredibly sensitive. Ye, for example, demonstrated an atomic clock that can register the difference in Earth’s gravity if you lift it up by just a millimeter. Ye, who’s also the director of CUbit, leads a center on campus funded by the National Science Foundation called Quantum Systems through Entangled Science and Engineering (Q-SEnSE).

He imagines using such devices to, for example, predict when a volcano is about to erupt by sensing the flow of magma miles below Earth’s surface. 

“For me, one of the most promising technological avenues is quantum sensors,” said Rey who has worked with Ye over the years to take atomic clocks to greater and greater levels of precision. “We’ve already seen that quantum can help us do better measurements.”

A team of engineers at CU Boulder is using different quantum sensors to detect methane leaking from natural gas operations in the West.

Meanwhile, CU Boulder’s Svenja Knappe and her colleagues employ a quantum sensor called an optically-pumped magnetometer, or OPM, to dive into the complex territory of the human brain.

“The first time I went to a neuroscience meeting, the neuroscientists there looked at me like I was from Mars,” said Knappe, associate professor in the Paul M. Rady Department of Mechanical Engineering

Knappe’s OPMs each measure about the size of two sugar cubes. They contain a group of atoms that change their orientation of their "spins," a strange property of atoms and particles, in response to the magnetic fields around them. It’s a bit like how the needle in a compass always points north. She and her colleagues are employing the sensors to measure the tiny blips of energy that neurons emit when humans move, think or even just breathe. 

Neuroscientists are already using helmets embedded with 128 of these sensors to collect maps of the brain’s activity, or magnetoencephalograms (MEGs). They are important tools for studying or diagnosing illnesses like schizophrenia and Parkinson’s Disease. To date, Knappe and her colleagues have sold sensors to about a dozen clients through a Boulder-based company called FieldLine.

 “This is not a technology that's 20 years out. Quantum sensors can make an impact on your life now,” she said.

 

Artist's depiction of an Earth-sized planet orbiting a star roughly 100 light-years from our own.

Artist's depiction of an Earth-sized planet orbiting a star roughly 100 light-years from our own. (Credit: NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center)

Quantum for probing the mysteries of the universe

By going smaller and ever more precise, scientists might also pursue questions that have eluded them for decades.

Jun Ye shares his team's new atomic clock, the world's most precise yet. (Credit: NIST)

Learn more about the power of frequency combs. (Credit: NIST)

For instance: What is dark matter?

This mysterious substance constitutes about 84% of the mass in the universe, but scientists have yet to identify what type of particle it’s made of. Dark matter is, as far as physicists can tell, completely invisible and rarely interacts with normal matter. But Ye suspects that some candidates for dark matter could bump into the atoms in his atomic clock—not very often, but often enough that he and his colleagues could, theoretically, detect the disturbance.

“Say you have a clock here in the U.S. and another clock somewhere near the North Pole,” Ye said. “If one clock was speeding up, while the other was slowing down, and if you have accounted for all other known effects, that might indicate that we’re seeing different fields pass Earth as it moves through the universe.”

Other researchers in Colorado are narrowing the search for dark matter using a different set of quantum technologies.

Quantum researcher Scott Diddams is turning quantum sensors toward space to look for planets circling stars far away from Earth. 

Diddams is a former physicist at NIST who recently joined CU Boulder as a professor in the Department of Electrical, Computer and Energy Engineering. He explained that when “exoplanets” orbit their home stars, they tug on those stars a little bit, causing them to wobble.

Telescopes on the ground can spot those wobbles, but the changes are very, very faint. 

“As a star is being pulled away from us, the colors of light look ever so slightly more red. As it’s being pulled toward us, its light will look slightly more blue,” he said. “And by slight, I mean less than one part in 1 billion.”

He uses a powerful type of laser called a frequency comb to help narrow in on that slight shift. More than 20 years ago, the physicist was part of the team that invented these lasers when he was a postdoctoral scientist at JILA—at first, researchers used them to count out the ticking in atomic clocks. But if you also install one of these tools in a telescope on the ground, Diddams said, it can act almost like a ruler for light waves. Astronomers can deploy these rulers to more precisely measure the color of light coming from distant stars, potentially finding planets hiding just out of view.

Diddams’ colleagues are already doing just that every night from two observatories on the ground. Teams led by Penn State have installed frequency combs at the McDonald Observatory in Texas and the Kitt Peak National Observatory in Arizona, and the researchers have plans for more.

“It’s a really interesting example of transitioning technology first developed at JILA out of the lab and into real experiments,” he said. 

 

 

Graphic of a laser heating up a nanomachine

Artist's depiction of a laser heating up bars of silicon many times thinner than the width of a human hair. (Credit: Steven Burrows/JILA)

Quantum for taking better images

When Antony van Leeuwenhoek first observed the green cells belonging to algae from lakes in the Netherlands, he was seeing the world at about 200 times its normal size.

Physicists Margaret Murnane and Henry Kapteyn have spent their careers trying to look deeper than that—roughly 100 to 1,000 times deeper. 

Margaret Murnane and Henry Kapteyn in their lab on campus

Margaret Murnane and Henry Kapteyn in their lab on campus. (Credit: Glenn Asakawa/CU Boulder)

A little more than a decade ago, the duo built the world’s first X-ray laser that could fit on a tabletop. And they did it by tapping into the quantum nature of electrons and atoms. 

The team uses a laser to pluck electrons in atoms, essentially making them vibrate violently—akin to what happens if you pluck a guitar string really hard. In the process, the atoms, like guitar strings, can snap, breaking apart but also emitting excess energy in the form of X-ray light. The resulting beams, which are today among the fastest microscopes on Earth, oscillate more than a quintillion, or a billion billion, times per second. 

Murnane and Kapteyn’s group at CU Boulder has used these lasers to better understand how heat flows in nanodevices thinner than the width of a human hair. They’ve also found that light can manipulate the magnetic properties of materials more than 500 times faster than scientists previously predicted.

NIST and Imec, a company that develops semiconductors and other devices, are already employing Murnane and Kapteyn’s lasers to design new nano-sized electronics. 
    
“Seeing is understanding,” said Murnane, a JILA fellow and distinguished professor of physics at CU Boulder. “We still can’t see everything we need to see to be able to understand nature.”

To build “the microscopes of tomorrow,” Murnane and Kapteyn helped launch a $24 million center on campus called STROBE with funding from the U.S. National Science Foundation. In the 1990s, they started a company called KM Labs to sell their X-ray lasers.

They’re also continuing to push the limits of what atoms are capable of. Kapteyn said that the team would like to one day create an X-ray laser so powerful that it could see inside human tissue. Such a machine would allow doctors to zoom in on specific regions of the body, and with much greater resolution than current X-rays. 

“There are a lot of quantum questions that are still outstanding in this area around how far we can push this technology,” said Kapteyn, JILA fellow and professor of physics.

 

Artist's depiction of a qubit formed from an ytterbium atom trapped in laser light.

Artist's depiction of a qubit formed from an ytterbium atom trapped in laser light. (Credit: Steven Burrows/JILA)

Quantum for making faster computers

There may be no quantum technology that gets as much hype as quantum computers.

Some of the largest technology companies in the world, including Google, Amazon, Microsoft and IBM, are trying their hand at developing computers that are based on unusual properties of quantum physics. Experts believe quantum computers could one day solve problems that even the largest supercomputers on Earth right now couldn’t. 

Cindy Regal talks to a group of women in front of a mural

Cindy Regal, center, helped to consult on a mural by artist Amanda Phingbodhipakkiya in Denver's Washington Park celebrating women in physics. (Credit: Amanda Phingboddhipakkiya)

IBM's Quantum System One quantum computer.

IBM's Quantum System One quantum computer. (Credit: CC photo via Wikimedia Commons)

But researchers at CU Boulder say quantum computers that can solve problems relevant to the lives of real people may still be a long way away. For one thing the quantum processors currently available often produce too many errors to do a lot of basic calculations.

“Quantum computers may be really good for the specific tasks they are designed for,” said Shuo Sun, a JILA fellow and assistant professor of physics at CU Boulder. “But they won’t be good at everything." 

Researchers at CU Boulder, however, are striving to design new and better qubits. Like the bits that run your home laptop, qubits form the basis for quantum computers. But they’re a lot more flexible: Qubits can take on values of zero or one, like normal bits, but they can also exist in a ghostlike state, or “superposition,” of zero and one at the same time. 

Cindy Regal, a fellow at JILA and associate professor of physics at CU Boulder, and her colleagues are using a technique called optical tweezing to make qubits out of neutral atoms, or atoms without a charge. Optical tweezers deploy laser beams to carefully move around and arrange those atoms. Scientists can then build complex lattices made up of atoms, carefully controlling how they interact with each other.

Sun, in contrast, is designing a different kind of qubit by implanting lone atoms inside diamonds and other crystals.

Regal noted that even if these qubits don’t wind up in a computer anytime soon, they can still help scientists answer new questions—allowing them to simulate, for example, the physics of weird states of matter in a controlled lab setting.

Some experts have even imagined quantum computers leading the hunt for new medicines. These devices might, decades from now, scan through large databases of molecules, looking for ones with the exact chemical behavior doctors want. 

In the end, Murnane said if quantum researchers want to bring their quantum technologies out of the lab, they need to continue to build connections with researchers beyond physics—collaborating with engineers, materials scientists, astrophysicists, biologists and more.

“If you want your research to have a big impact, you need to look beyond your field,” Murnane said.

Ye noted that the most amazing quantum technologies may be the ones that scientists haven’t dreamed up yet. Like van Leeuwenhoek discovered four centuries ago, the deeper you look into the world, the more surprises you’ll find. 

“It’s just like when people first invented a microscope,” Ye said. “There’s an entire world down there filled with bacteria, and we never realized that.”