Carnegie FAQs
FAQs
General:
A: The University of Colorado Boulder is proud to serve as the operational and administrative host institution for the Sustainability Classification, working alongside the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching and the American Council on Education. As host, CU Boulder manages program operations, administers the application, facilitates application reviews, and builds a nationwide community of practice among institutions pursuing the classification. This role helps advance recognition of sustainability and climate leadership across higher education.
A: To determine whether your institution is eligible to apply, visit the Institution Search (https://carnegieclassifications.acenet.edu/institutions/) page. Listed institutions are eligible to apply for the Elective Classification for Sustainability.
A: There are a number of institutions with multiple branch campuses under one Basic Classification. Branch campuses of institutions that have a Basic Classification are eligible to apply for separate classification if they have historically been an independent institution, have discrete local leadership, and have a distinct student body and community with which they partner. In these cases, please consult our updated policy (http://carnegieclassifications.acenet.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Carnegie-Branch-Campus-Policy_April-2018.pdf).
A: The application framework PDF is available at: https://www.colorado.edu/sustainability/carnegie-elective-classification-sustainability. The application framework can be used to view a list of all questions that appear in the application.
Access to the online application is available at: GivePulse (https://www.givepulse.com/event/829683-carnegie-elective-classification-for-sustainability). Institutional representatives will be prompted to select the first-time classification application before being directed to a payment page. After the payment is complete, the representative will be automatically redirected to the application portal. Representatives will be invited to establish a GivePulse account (at no cost) to return to their draft application.
A: The application fee covers the costs of the classification administration and dataset maintenance.
A: The classification is intended to invite wide participation, and no college or university will be excluded from participating due to an inability to cover the application fee. If your institution would like to request a waiver, email CarnegieSustain@colorado.edu with the subject line “Waiver Request – Your Institution Name” and provide a paragraph explaining the context.
A: Campuses that wish to withdraw their participation in the 2027 cycle must submit a refund request by August 3, 2026. No refunds will be processed after August 3, 2026. To request a refund, please send an email to CarnegieSustain@colorado.edu.
A: Applications for the 2027 cycle must be initiated by July 17, 2026.
A: The deadline for submitting the application is December 4, 2026.
A: Based on the pilot cohort, the average estimated range is 150-250 hours per application. This is highly dependent on a number of campus-specific factors, including who serves on the team putting together the application, what data is already collected or easily accessible, and leadership approval processes. We encourage applicants to track their hours and share both internally with leadership and with the University of Colorado Boulder team when requested.
A: Campuses may use data from their three most recent academic years – AY 2022-2023, 2023-2024 and 2024-2025.
Campuses may use the data that provides the best representation of their sustainability efforts: data provided for one question or set of questions can be from one academic year and data provided for another question or set of questions can be from a different academic year. For each question and/or example, indicate the year that the data represents.
A: For general inquiries regarding the application process, assistance with technical issues, or guidance related to application content, please contact the University of Colorado Boulder team at CarnegieSustain@colorado.edu.
Application:
A: After your institution has registered for the application and the primary representative has accepted the GivePulse account (as necessary), you can return to the application by following these instructions:
- Log in to https://www.givepulse.com/
- From the account navigation in the top right corner, select “My Activity” and then “Surveys.”
- Select “First-Time Carnegie Elective Classification for Sustainability”
A: While all institutions will be applying for the Sustainability Classification for the first time during the 2027 cycle, those that receive the designation will be eligible to apply for “reclassification” in 6 years (2033). Labeling the application as “first-time” helps the Carnegie team track data across cycles and distinguish from future “reclassification” applications.
A: Though the process of compiling responses to the application questions will likely involve many individuals from the applicant institution, it is strongly recommended that only one person be responsible for filling out and submitting the online application itself. Collaborators can be granted access to the application under the “Collaborators” tab. However, the individual listed in the “Applicant’s Contact Information” section of the application should be the same individual who submits the application.
The primary representative can add collaborators to the application by following these instructions:
- Log in to https://www.givepulse.com/
- From the account navigation in the top right corner, select “My Activity” and then “Surveys.”
- Select “First-Time Carnegie Elective Classification for Sustainability”
- Within the application, select the tab called “Collaborators”. Use this section to add the names and email addresses of the individuals who will co-prepare the application. Added collaborators can access the application by completing steps one through three.
A: Yes. The application framework includes a list of all questions that appear in the application. There is also an accompanying guidebook with thorough descriptions of the purpose of certain questions and the type of information that is expected in applicants’ responses. It is strongly recommended that institutions use this framework and guidebook when collecting data and drafting responses to the application questions. Transferring responses from the framework to the online application should be the last step in the process prior to submitting the application.
A: Yes. Applicants can view the application sections, finish parts of the application, save drafts, and come back to it later as needed. The application framework can also be used to view a list of all questions that appear in the application.
A: Yes. Applicants that have created an account on GivePulse may save drafts of the online application and then edit and/or continue later. You will need to log in to retain access to the online application and save it in draft mode. As a GivePulse user, your role as a “Collaborator” on the platform will allow you to see that the application is automatically saving your work as you go. If you forget your password, you can easily reset it.
A: Yes. Most application questions require responses that do not exceed a certain word limit, and the text boxes will not allow for more than the word limit. The word limits are indicated in the application framework for each question. You will find a word count calculator under each text box in the online framework. If a response provided by an applicant exceeds the word limit, the online application software will only submit the maximum number of words allowed for that question, resulting in an incomplete response. Therefore, it is recommended that applicants draft their responses in a word-processing application (e.g., Microsoft Word, Google Docs) and use the word-count feature before cutting and pasting text into the online application. Upon pasting your answer into the online application, please make sure to read it fully to make sure that the full answer was captured.
A: No. Paragraph marks in a response are not treated as words in the word count limit.
A: Applicants should provide web links to relevant campus resources where requested in the application. There will be specific fields to add weblinks, where allowable. Reviewers may want to examine websites for additional clarification of the responses in the application.
A: Application instructions will specify acceptable documentation formats. In general, applicants are encouraged to provide publicly accessible URLs as supporting materials. Where file uploads are permitted within the application platform, specific guidance will be provided.
A: The response boxes in the application only accept non-formatted text (i.e., no font enhancements, such as bolding, italicizing, or underlining, and no tables). In addition, the response boxes do not allow embedded hyperlinks.
A: It is not advisable to leave any sections blank. If you cannot respond by providing evidence, explain why the evidence does not exist and what the campus is doing to be able to provide the evidence in the future.
A: Each application is reviewed in its entirety by the same reviewer (with multiple reviewers reviewing each application); thus, acronyms may be used provided they are defined at first reference. If there is any potential for confusion, terms should be written out fully. Departmental abbreviations may carry different meanings across campuses and should be spelled out to ensure clarity and consistency for reviewers.
Review & Classification Decision:
A: Multiple reviewers will evaluate each application in its entirety. Reviewers will be selected and trained rigorously to effectively evaluate all the evidence provided by institutions. Reviewers will need to reach a consensus on each applicant institution to determine if it will receive the classification. If a consensus is not reached, the application will move to the Tier 2 review, which includes individuals with extensive experience in reviewing applications in the past.
A: Applications for the Carnegie Elective Classification for Sustainability are reviewed by trained panels of scholars and practitioners with diverse experience across higher education institution types. Reviewers are selected for both subject-matter expertise and their ability to assess sustainability efforts within varied institutional contexts.
A: The results of the 2027 Carnegie Elective Classification for Sustainability application cycle will be announced in June 2027. Only those institutions that receive the classification will be announced. Institutions that are not classified during this cycle are notified privately.
A: All applicants will be formally notified of the outcome of the review process. Additionally, summary feedback will be provided to support institutional learning and future improvement.
A: All applications are treated as confidential. Applicants will have the opportunity to indicate whether they wish their application to be made available to qualified researchers, consistent with the Carnegie Foundation’s strict research protocols.
The information provided in the application will be used to assess whether an institution’s commitment to sustainability and climate action is deep, integrated, and pervasive. The Foundation will publicly identify only those institutions that receive the classification.
A: Application cycles will open every three years; our next cycle will open in 2029, with classification decisions in 2030.