Phys3220 Survey

Please read the following consent document before proceeding with the survey below.
Pressing submit at the end of this survey signals your consent.

INFORMED CONSENT DOCUMENT - “Physics Education Research” Project
 

This brief survey will provide us with extremely valuable information about your thoughts on this course, and on the use of clickers in upper-division physics. It should take no longer than 20 minutes to complete.

This survey counts as credit for one homework problem on HW13. You must complete it by Wednesday, Dec 10 to receive credit.

Your responses to this survey will NOT affect your grade. All names/IDs will be deleted before Profs. Pollock and DeWolfe reviews the responses, and they will not review them until after grades have been turned in. They will receive a separate list of who participated for the purposes of assigning homework credit.

Please enter your name (Last, First):
Please enter the last 6 digits of your student ID number:

About Your Experience in PHYS 3220

  1. Please read each statement below (on the left) about Quantum and check the box which indicates how strongly you agree with the statement.
     
    Strongly Agree
    Agree
    Neutral
    Disagree
    Strongly Disagree
    Not answered
    I think quantum mechanics is an interesting subject

    My intuition is useful in solving PHYS 3220-level quantum problems

    I am generally able to do the mathematical calculations required in PHYS 3220.
    Throughout the course of PHYS 3220, I built on and deepened my understanding of material from PHYS 2170/2130 (General Physics 3: Modern Physics or an equivalent course.)
    The instructor regularly made connections between PHYS 3220 and PHYS 2170/2130 (or an equivalent course).
    During PHYS 3220 connections between mathematical techniques and important physical concepts were made regularly.
    I usually understand what the professor says in lecture in this class.

  2. Please rate how well you feel the following elements of the course were connected ....
  3.  
    Very Connected
    Connected
    Somewhat connected
    Disconnected

    Very Disconnected

    Not answered
    In-class lecture TO In-class clicker questions
    In-class time TO Homework

    In-class time TO Exams

    Tutorials TO Homework
    Homework TO Exams

  4. Even when I successfully calculate the answer to a problem in PHYS 3220, I don't understand the physics of the problem.
    Not answered
    Never
    Rarely
    Sometimes
    Often
    Always


  5. I spent hours per week on the homework, on average.

  6. I typically spend hours working with other students on PHYS 3220 homework OUTSIDE of scheduled sessions.

    Can you tell us more about these extra study sessions (outside of scheduled sessions)? For example, how many students, how often, how long, do folks come with their worked solutions to check or do you work through the problems from scratch?


  7. Assignments in this class were due on Wednesdays. I typically began work on the assignment on....
    Not answered
    Mon
    Tues
    Wed
    Thurs
    Fri
    Sat
    Sun

  8. Please name 1-2 things you would be disappointed to see change in this course.


  9. Please name 1-2 things you would recommend to be changed about this course in the future, which would have helped you learn more.

Use of Clickers in Phys3220 and more broadly in upper-division physics

  1. During lecture, how often were in-class clicker questions used in Phys3220?
    Not answered
    Never or Almost never
    About once per week
    About once per lecture
    2-3 times per lecture
    More than 3 times per lecture


  2. Please rate how useful for your learning each of the following class activities are in Phys3220 (Mark N/A if you did not attempt to use this resource for help):
    1. Pure Lecture Presentation (only instructor talking):
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A   
    2. Use of Clickers:
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A  
    3. Use of in-class Whiteboard Activities:
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A  
    4. Textbook or Course Readings:
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A   
    5. Homework and/or Course Assignments:
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A   
    6. Studying for exams :
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A   
    7. Posted online clicker questions:
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A   
    8. Posted online lecture notes :
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A   
    9. Other posted online resources (e.g. HW solutions, etc):
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A   
    10. Monday and Tuesday homework study session:
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A  
    11. Optional Friday Tutorials:
         Completely useless   Mostly useless   Somewhat useful   Useful   Very useful. . . . . .   N/A   
      If these optional Friday sessions were no longer offered, would you recommend using these tutorials as in-class activities?
      Definitely Not recommended     Not recommended   Neutral   Recommended     Definitely Recommend . . . . . . .    N/A
       

    Please comment on the homework assignments in this course. For example, How did they differ from other physics courses (if at all)? What aspects were helpful or not helpful for your learning? What kinds of skills do you feel you gained from these homeworks?

    Please comment on the homework help sessions in this course (if you attended). For example, How did they differ from other physics courses (if at all)? What aspects were helpful or not helpful for your learning? What kinds of skills do you feel you gained from these homework help sessions?

    Please comment on the optional Friday tutorials in this course (if you attended). For example, What aspects were helpful or not helpful for your learning? What kinds of skills do you feel you gained from these optional Friday tutorials?

    Please comment here on anything else you found useful for your learning, or comment on something in the class that required your time but was not useful for learning:


  3. Please rate how much each of the following approaches are useful in helping you learn fundamental derivations in physics (even if not used in this particular course)
  4.  
    Completely useless
    Mostly useless
    Somewhat useful
    Useful

    Very Useful

    Not answered
    Chalk board presentation by faculty
    Chalk board presentation with individual student's contributing to faculty derivation

    Chalk board presentation in conjunction with targeted clicker questions

    Working through derivations as part of HW

  5. Please rate how much you enjoyed each of the following class activities in Phys3220 [where "enjoyed" is meant in the sense of academic or intellectual pleasure] (Mark N/A if you did not attempt to use this resource):
    1. Pure Lecture Presentation (only instructor talking):
         Strongly Dislike    Dislike    Neutral   Like    Strongly Like. . . . . .   N/A   
    2. Use of Clickers:
         Strongly Dislike    Dislike    Neutral   Like    Strongly Like. . . . . .   N/A   
    3. Use of in-class Whiteboarding Activities:
         Strongly Dislike    Dislike    Neutral   Like    Strongly Like. . . . . .   N/A   
    4. Textbook or Course Readings:
         Strongly Dislike    Dislike    Neutral   Like    Strongly Like. . . . . .   N/A   
    5. Homework and/or Course Assignments:
         Strongly Dislike    Dislike    Neutral   Like    Strongly Like. . . . . .   N/A   
    6. Working/discussing with fellow students in lecture:
         Strongly Dislike    Dislike    Neutral   Like    Strongly Like. . . . . .   N/A   
    7. Working/discussing with fellow students on the homework:
         Strongly Dislike    Dislike    Neutral   Like    Strongly Like. . . . . .   N/A     

    8. Optional Friday Tutorials:
         Strongly Dislike    Dislike    Neutral   Like    Strongly Like. . . . . .   N/A   

  6. Knowing the right answers is the only important part of the clicker questions.
    Strongly disagree    Somewhat disagree    Not sure   Somewhat agree   Strongly agree . . . . . . . Not answered

    Why or why not? Please explain in the space below.


  7. To what extent does your instructor usually encourage student-to-student discussion about clicker questions in class?
    Not answered
    Does not allow discussion
    Allows discussion, but does not encourage it, and a small fraction of students discuss
    Allows discussion, but does not encourage it, and a large fraction of students discuss
    Encourages discussion, and a small fraction of students discuss
    Encourages discussion, and a large fraction of students discuss

  8. When your instructor gives your class a typical clicker question AND you are allowed to talk with others, what do you usually do?
    Not answered
    Does not apply--we are usually not allowed to talk with other students
    I rarely use a clicker in this course
    I guess the answer and do not check with other students
    I actively think about the question independently and arrive at an answer without speaking or listening to other students
    I listen to other students' answers and/or reasoning
    I actively participate in discussions with other students around me

  9. During lecture, how often did you discuss the ideas being presented with other students sitting near you?
    Not answered
    Never or Almost never
    About once per week
    About once per lecture
    2-3 times per lecture
    More than 3 times per lecture

  10. How useful for your learning did you find these discussions when you did have them:
    Completely useless    Mostly useless   Somewhat useful    Useful   Very Useful . . . . . . .    Not answered

  11. How comfortable do you feel discussing the course content with your peers during clicker questions?
    Very uncomfortable    Somewhat uncomfortable    Neutral   Somewhat comfortable    Very comfortable . . . . . . .    Not answered

  12. How comfortable do you feel asking questions or offering comments during lecture?
    Very uncomfortable    Somewhat uncomfortable    Neutral   Somewhat comfortable    Very comfortable . . . . . . .    Not answered

  13. In this class, how important is it for you to articulate your reasoning either to your peers or during whole class discussion?
    Not important at all    Not very important    Somewhat important    Important    Very Important . . . . . . .    Not answered

    Why? Please explain in the space below.


  14. For the clicker questions and discussion in this course, please explain why you felt they were particularly useful or not useful for your learning.


  15. What percentage of the time you spent doing homework were you working together with other students?
    Never    less than 25%    25%-50%    50%-75%    greater than 75% . . . . . . .    Not answered

  16. If clickers are used in upper-division courses, what would you recommend to your instructor to maximize usefulness of clickers for your learning?

    A. Recommended number of clicker questions:
    Not answered
    ~1/week  
    ~1/lecture  
    2-3/lecture  
    4-5/lecture  
    >5/lecture
    B. Recommended timing of clicker questions:
    Not answered
    Interspersed with lecture   
    All following main lecture  
    Doesn't matter
    C. Recommended approach to student-student discussion during questions:
    Not answered
    No student-student dicussion
    Should allow, but not encourage
    Should encourage students to discuss questions
    Doesn't matter
    D. Preference regarding individual time to think during questions:
    Not answered
    I prefer having time to think and vote as individuals, with no student-student discussion
    I prefer having time to think and vote as individuals, followed by student-student discussion and revote
    I prefer having time to think individually, but then OK to allow discussion before voting
    I prefer immediately being allowed to discuss with my peers to figure out answer.
    Doesn't matter
    E. Recommendation regarding target level for most clicker question:
    Not answered
    Questions where I know the answer right away without thinking
    Questions where I can easily figure out the right answer without thinking much
    Questions where I have to think some or check with my neighbor in order to figure out the answer
    Questions where I have to think pretty hard or debate with my neighbor, but can then usually figure out the right answer
    Questions where I have to think hard or debate with my neighbor, and may or may not figure out the right answer
    Any other recommendations or comments regarding best use of clickers?

  17. How useful for your learning is the addition of clicker questions compared to pure lecture with no clicker questions?
    Not answered
    Having clicker questions is much more useful
    Having clicker questions is more useful
    It's about the same
    Pure lecture with no clicker questions is more useful
    Pure lecture with no clicker questions is much more useful

  18. Would you recommend that other instructors, who teach this course in the future, use clickers?
    Definitely Not recommended     Not recommended   Neutral   Recommended     Definitely Recommend . . . . . . .    Not answered

  19. In general, would you recommend using clicker questions in upper-level physics courses (2210 and higher)?
    Definitely not recommmended   Not recommended   Neutral   Recommended    Highly recommended . . . . . . .    Not answered

  20. If used as you suggested would be most effective for your learning , would you recommend using clicker questions in upper-level physics courses (2210 and higher)?
    Definitely not recommmended   Not recommended   Neutral   Recommended    Highly recommended . . . . . . .    Not answered

  21. Overall, how do you feel about this course?
    Not answered
    Awful course
    Not a good course
    Neutral
    Good course
    Great course

  22. Regardless of how you feel about it, how much did you learn in this course?
    Not answered
    Almost nothing
    A small amount
    A reasonable amount
    Quite a bit
    A great deal

  23. To what extent have you made gains in the following as a result of Phys3220

    A. Understanding physics:
       Not at all   A little    Some    A lot    A great deal . . . . . .    Not answered
    B. Problem solving ability :
       Not at all   A little    Some    A lot   A great deal . . . . . .    Not answered
    C. Ability to discuss/argue about science :
       Not at all   A little    Some    A lot   A great deal . . . . . .    Not answered

Finished? Click on the "Submit" button if you agree to the terms below. Thanks!