Must there be a "Self-Existent" First Cause?
Principles and definitions:
-
PSR (Principle of Sufficient Reason) has two parts:
(1st part) There must be an explanation of the existence of any
being.
(2nd part) There must be an explanation for any positive fact whatsoever.
-
A dependent being depends for its existence on something external to
itself.
-
A self-existent being is self-sufficient. It nature is such that it cannot
fail to exists.
PSR entails that nothing "just happens" to exist. Everything that exists
is either a dependent or an self-existent being - either contains the reason
of its own existence (self-existent) or does not contain the reason of
its own existence because it depends on something external to itself.
If this is given, then we can show that there must be a self-existent
being.
The Argument
-
Suppose that all beings are dependent.
-
The set of all dependent beings requires a sufficient reason as much as
any of its members does. (Required by the second part of PSR.)
-
The being that contains the sufficient reason cannot be internal to the
set of all dependent beings, for then one of the dependent beings would
contain the reason of its own existence.
-
Therefore it must be external to the set of all dependent beings.
-
But whatever is external to the set of all dependent beings must be an
self-existent being.
-
Therefore there is (at least one) self-existent being on which the set
of all dependent beings depends for its existence.
Problems
-
Why think the world depends on just one self-existent being?
-
Is PSR true?
-
What about the behavior of subatomic particles? Is there a "sufficient
reason" in their case? Is the
2nd part of PSR true?
-
Must the set of dependent beings as a whole have a cause? Is the 2nd part
of PSR true?
-
How do we know that the world is not an "self-existent" being?
It's "logically possible" that it's not?
But it's "logically possible" that God does not exist.
-
Why did God create the world?
Was it necessary? Then isn't the world necessary too?
Personal explanation and PSR.