Serious science for dedicated enthusiasts, March 24, 2002.
Reviewer: chrisindenver from Aurora, CO United States
"Sleeping with the Enemy" by Karl Giberson in Research News & Opportunities in Science and Theology. Note this is a publication of the Templeton Foundation.
"Has Science Found God?" by Kenneth Silber in Tech Central Station.
Perspectives
in Science and the
Christian
Faith by Gary DeBoer
takes some getting used
to...
, March 4, 2003
Reviewer: Lester M. Stacey (see more about me) from Las Vegas,
Nevada
USA
I first read this book two years ago and I found the ideas presented
to be very unsettling. I needed to set the book aside and think about
more
ordinary aspects of the world for a while. The fact is, however, that
Dr.
Stenger describes reality and there's no getting away from reality. Now
my investigations lead me back to the implications of time symmetry.
And
happily, I have Dr. Stenger's book on hand to turn to again. This time,
unafraid, I am finding the experience extremely satisfying.
I agree with the detailed reviews written below. I would also like to add an important bit of information about trust. Anyone who has investigated this field becomes familiar with the corruption that has taken place. Science is used as propaganda to support dogmatic conclusions. Speculation is too easily mutated into whatever covert form of mysticism the author secretly harbors and seeks to spread. Therefore, it is necessary to exert significant effort to find a guide into the stranger regions of reality who can be trusted to NOT MISLEAD. Victor Stenger is someone who can be trusted.
This makes all the difference in the world.
I've had the pleasure of receiving several kind personal responses to questions I posed to Dr. Stenger by way of his friendly and helpful website. I was delighted to find that he is genuinely interested in furthering human understanding and improving the human condition. He is without any hidden agenda. What you see is what you get. He is interested in exposing deception instead of practicing it. He sincerely cares about individuals who struggle with the almost insurmountable challenge of trying to understand what's really going on here in the world. He provides a sense of much-needed balance in an effort that often seems to threaten one's sanity.
And given the fact that what's really going on here takes some time for a person to adapt to, please take your time and let the ideas filter in gradually. Whether we like it or not, the strangeness of the world isn't going to go away. In fact, things become increasingly more interesting the more closely they are examined. And this is why having a trusty guide who's familiar with the topography is so important.
I am please to see that Dr. Stenger has an important new book coming
out that will further help those of us who need technological expertise
in exposing the mischief of the dogmatists. "Has Science Found God?"
promises
to provide further comfort and support for those of us who just want to
approach the truth unadulterated. If truth is defined as "good" (no
matter
how uncomfortable it makes us), then Dr. Stenger is firmly on the side
of the good. He's a great and welcome ally.
Serious science for dedicated enthusiasts, March 24, 2002.
Reviewer: chrisindenver from Aurora, CO United States
First of all, I'd like to start with a caveat. I gave this book 5 stars, but that assumes the reader has a college education or a very technical background. For someone not used to college-level writing, I would recommend avoiding this book. Having said that, I thought this book was amazing. My head is still spinning from all the detailed, technical information about quantum physics and relativity. Without getting bogged down in the actual mathematics, this book tells you just about everything you might want to know about modern physics.
Some of the best and most original writing is actually at the end, where Stenger presents his ideas on symmetry and how it relates to cosmology and the history of the universe. However, everything else in the book leads up to this, and there are plenty of references to previous chapters.
Stenger's concluding paradigm is simple, logical, and aesthetic, and definitely meets his own criterion of parsimony, or Occam's razor. Parsimony is a common theme in this and Stenger's other books, and he does a great job of using it to critique and analyze the various theories and philosophical interpretations of modern physics.
Again, I would recommend this book to anyone comfortable with
college-level
reading, but I would also love to see Stenger's concluding ideas
summarized in another, less technical and more accessible format, for a
wider audience.
Would have five
stars if
he stuck to one thesis objective..., November 8, 2001 Reviewer:
IndiAndy
(see
more about me) from an evolving state of enlightenment I approve of
the non-mathematical descriptions this book offers the intended
audience.
It elucidates some important quantitative principles in a
comprehensible
language (e.g. the Principle of Least Action; the Lagrangian and
Hamiltonian;
the 'Wave-Particle Duality' and Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle;
state
vectors, phase, superposition, Gauge Invariance, Relativity symmetry,
spin,
and Lorentz transformations). I have enjoyed using this book as part of
a bridge to step across the yawning gulf between popular
(non-mathematical)
and rigorously quantitative textbooks on Quantum theory (Quantum
Electrodynamics
& Quantum Field Theory). I especially liked Chapter 7 'Taming
Infinity'
where the Feynman Wheeler Interaction Theory and Feynman's QED are
beautifully
presented for intellectual consumption. He seems especially aligned
with
Feynman's views of the particle nature of matter.
The author has carefully placed key words in bold type throughout the book that indicate their inclusion in a generous glossary of terms near the end of the book. I have grown to appreciate this as is a valuable feature in several books at this reading level. The chapters are broken into intellectually digestible size with a fair amount of diagrams to illustrate certain concepts visually. Apparently a part of his agenda in this book, as well as in several of his other publications, is to try to correct (control) superstitious creationist (wrong) thinking concerning the origin of our Universe and equally incorrect mystical interpretations of reality. Vic flat out states that the Universe '...had no beginning and was not created.' For example, Dr. Stenger seems compelled to narrowly target the logic of theistic physicists such as Polkinghorne and Ross. In addition, he seems to be inclined to marginalize the fact that particles are a manifestation of force field excitations/waves in a quantum field description of the phenomena in our Universe. After carefully reading his book (with sincere & open minded interest) I have come to strongly suspect that he fears an association of 'spooky action at a distance' (i.e. fields & waves) with a an omnipotent, omnipresent, omniscient, and eternal (timeless) Supreme Being who, God forbid, might have created everything (including the laws of physics). He also goes after the philosophical interpretation of QM that speculates that reality is mystically created or changed by observation & measurement. One has to wonder if maybe the author might have had some kind of traumatic religious disenchantment in his earlier travels through life that subsequently motivates him to prove that God doesn't exist. I would like to point out that I once had a bout of serious religious disillusionment from which I recovered to a simple & humble attitude and outlook towards a theological ontology of reality that is in harmony with, indeed even embraces, physical reality as we understand it from a scientific perspective. It's possible to do this and not risk your intelligence, reasonability, sanity, and objectivity towards reality. I may be projecting something that isn't really there with this guy so I apologize if that's the case. Honestly I have to confess that I don't know (for sure) what motivates this man as I cannot read his mind. I can, however, surmise from what he has written that he finds the possibility of a spiritual realm untenable. Well, live & let live right?
It must be noted that one of his major points in this book is we exist in a (bi-directional) time symmetric Universe that may be one of many in the 'Multiverse'. This is most interesting and would make a book in itself without all the other anti-superstitious stuff. I believe that he could have left his arguments against the creative design of the Universe in (a revised version of?) his other book 'The Unconscious Quantum' to keep this particular book more focused towards the subjects of the sub-title: 'Symmetry, Simplicity, and Multiple Universes'. Ironically, his arguments for a timeless reality reinforce my view of an eternal Spirit whom I believe is responsible for, and continues to sustain, more than we can ever achieve in defining the reality he has created. I choose to call this Spirit God. Well now you know my perspective. I like to try to keep an open mind. If I'm wrong, and I very well might be, then I haven't lost anything, just a little mental time in a timeless universe.
All this said I hope you don't get the wrong impression of my
respect
towards what Mr. Stenger has done with this great book. He has
challenged
us to be freethinking skeptics and to recognize the hocus-pocus
philosophical
fluff that is frequently published in the mystical/speculative
interpretations
concerning the nature of reality at the quantum level. I loved the book
because the majority of it lent itself as a great reference to
introductory
Quantum Mechanics. His writing is succinct (no fluff), objective and
didactic.
I recommend "Timeless Reality" to anyone (theistic or otherwise)
interested
in exploring the deeply mysterious and equally edifying adventure of
Quantum
Reality. I hope this comes out in paperback so that more can benefit
from
it as I have. My sincere appreciation goes out to this author. Thanks
Vic!
Ciao, IndiAndy