Risk, Climatic Variability, and the Study of Southwestern Prehistory: An evolutionary perspective (Larson et al 1996)


Dendrocronological data for the region of the Anasazi in the Vermillion Cliffs and northern Black Mesa between 900 and 1300.

Larson et al. (1996) make two basic arguments in this paper (1) they believe that evolutionary theory holds a great deal   of promise for understanding both specific events and the overall pattern of southwestern prehistory and (2) they advocate and  approach that incorporates high-resolution dendroclimatic reconstructions of inter annual climatic variation and extreme climatic events.
Larson et al (1996) present new dendrological data consisting of the Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI)  reconstructions of June soil  moisture rates, which provide significant insights into the ecological and economic impacts of climate on the Anasazi of the Vermillion Cliffs and northern Black Mesa regions between A.D. 900 and 1300.

They believe a selectionist framework provides a clear theoretical rationale for focusing on climatic variability in the Southwest. They argue that the Southwest was always in risk and that the adaptation of the Anasazi people to the Vermillion Cliffs and northern Black Mesa regions was being shaped by risk conditions. Adaptive strategies included specialized agriculture, dependence on storage, and exchange of food between settlements.

The abandonment of the region implies a catastrophic failure of the adaptation shaped by the previous 400-600 years of selection-driven-evolution.

STUDY AREA

The following map presents the location of the Anasazi regions, the major drainages, geographic features, and the general location of the primary tree-ring sites


 

POPULATION LEVELS

Figure 2 presents a composite of the relative population reconstructions for a number of areas in the northern  Southwest. There is clear evidence of increasing populations levels, population densities, and large villages size throughout the Anasazi region over time.



The Anasazi were living under risk conditions.  The high climatic variability caused hardship on the population.  For an agriculturist communities drought is the most significant factor that can decrease agricultural yields in arid lands

RESULTS

Climatic reconstruction


This are the results of an annual dendroclimatic reconstruction of the PDSI for June, representing a critical agricultural period for the northern South West.   The PDSI is based on empirical water balance approcah ans is widely uses as an indicator of the severity and duration of agricultural droughts.


The approach utilized tree-ring data from 4 locations (Figure 1).  The tree ring series extends from A.D. 95 to 1986.  The indexes from all tree-ring cores and from all 4 sites, for corresponding years, were average to produce a single regional index value for each year.   Based on the correlation between tree-rings and PDSI from 1987 to 1986  the PSCI was obtained for the entire record (A.D. 95 to 1986).  Figures 4a and 4b.








The results can be summarized into:



Figure 6 is a composite illustration of changes in the levels of climatic variability, increase intensity of exchange, and increase dependence on storage on Back Mesa.  There is a strong association between the two episodes of very high temporal variability in rainfall and soil moisture between A.D. 900 and 1150 and increase in intensity of exchange (red and orange imported) and increase dependence in storage.


CONCLUSION


There is a link between climatic variability with directional trends in aggregation, storage, exchange, and other tactics that enhance the stability of specialized agriculture strategies (Larson., et al., 1996).
Home
Location
History
Mystery
           Environmenatl stress
           Collapse of an economic trade system
           Warfare
           Religion crisis
References