Reading Reflection Questions

 

Allen Chapter 1

(Click to view reading in HTML)

 


Allen provides a list of occupations on pages 2 & 3 (secretary, CEO, soldier, hair stylist, janitor, basketball player, hotel maid, manager, elementary school teacher, interior decorator, nurse, welfare recipient, plastic surgeon, female impersonator, gang member, truck driver, gardener, special education student, chemist, rap artist, and beauty queen). When you picture each of these occupations, what do you notice about the gender, race, class, sexuality, age, and ability characteristics you presume for each? Why do you think particular images spring so readily to mind?

 

What is problematic about the assumption that –isms are ‘simply’ the behaviors of bad people? (p.4). What do you think about this statement?

 

On page 5, Allen says “people rarely talk openly about topics like race or racism when they are in mixed groups.  Why is that?  Well, these subjects often are difficult to discuss or even acknowledge.  They may arouse uncomfortable responses, such as anxiety, fear, shame, guilt, anger, frustration, hostility, or confusion.” What experiences have you had talking about –isms, and what feelings have those conversations evoked? Think of both positive and negative experiences you’ve had talking about difference. What characterized each of those interactions?

 

Why does Allen use the term difference instead of diversity?

 

How does she use the word ‘matters’?

 

Why does difference matter according to Allen?

 

How are “others” defined in relationship to a social norm (p.12)? How does this relate to Allen’s idea that “We often define ourselves in opposition to others:  “I know who I am because I am not you.” (p.17)

 

If you had to describe yourself using only four social identity groups, which would you use? How would you feel about having to limit your description of yourself in this way?

 

What do you think Dr. Allen means when she says that in this book “we will investigate how discourse ‘produces, maintains, and/or resists systems of power and inequality.’”(p.16)?

 

How is personal identity different from social identity, and how does the process of socialization work?

 

How can stereotypes both be natural and helpful and problematic and harmful?

 

Read, reflect on and answer the questions Allen poses on page 31.

 

After reading this chapter, how do you understand the social constructionists’ school of thought?

 

Flick Chapters 1-4

 

Chapter 1

 

How does Flick differentiate between the Conventional Discussion and Understanding Processes?

 

How is conventional discussion different from dialogue?

 

What is the Debate Culture according to Flick?

 

What is the difference between approaching the Understanding Process as a Technique vs. approaching it as a living technology?

 

Why, according to Flick, do we need to know and use the Understanding Process?

 

Why is the Understanding Process important from an Organizational Standpoint?

 

Why is the Understanding Process important to our ability to engage differences productively?

 

Chapter 2

 

Does Flick believe that there is value in Debate?  Explain your answer.

 

How is critical thinking related to the Understanding Process?

 

What are the fundamental differences between the Understanding Process and Conventional Discussion? How do you understand these differences?  What would they look like in practice?

 

Study the chart on pages 36-37, be able to discuss and summarize its content.

 

Chapter 3

 

What does Flick suggest are the rewards of using the Understanding Process?

 

Why is practice important?

 

Flick suggests that to use the Understanding Process, it “only takes one.” Are you inclined to agree or disagree? What are the advantages and disadvantages we might face if we accept this claim?

 

How can the Understanding Process help us to “stay with our differences?” How might this be beneficial to our understanding of Difference in organizational contexts?

 

How can using the Understanding Process transform our culture according to Flick?

 

Chapter 4

 

What are Mind-Models?

 

How does the concept of Mind-Models relate to other terms or concepts with which you are familiar?

 

What happens when people approach a situation from different Mind-Models?

 

How can this be complicated by power differences?

 

Flick Chapters 6-9

 

Chapter 6

 

How can using the Understanding Process help to transform destructive conflict?

 

How does Flick’s example help you to understand the Understanding Process in action?

 

What questions or challenges does this example raise for you?

 

Chapter 7

 

How can the Understanding Process help to “bridge the Diversity Divide?”

 

What is authentic healing and what are the conditions that support it?

 

How does Flick’s example help you to understand the Understanding Process in action?

 

What questions or challenges does this example raise for you?

 

Chapter 8

 

How can the Understanding Process help to transform groups into inclusive, multi-disciplinary teams?

 

How does Flick’s example help you to understand the Understanding Process in action?

 

What questions or challenges does this example raise for you?

 

Chapter 9

 

How can the Understanding Process help enhance civility in our public conversations?

 

How does Flick’s example help you to understand the Understanding Process in action?

 

What questions or challenges does this example raise for you?

 

 

Deetz & Simpson
 (Click to view reading in HTML)

 

 


How do Deetz/Simpson propose that we engage in a ‘politically responsive constructionist’ mode of communication?

 

What do they mean by this?

 

How is this similar to and/or different from other conceptions of dialogue?

 

How do they argue that this approach is rooted in responsiveness to difference in organizational contexts?

 

What would this look like in practice?

 

What questions are you left with after reading this piece?

 

Rosenblum & Travis pp. 481-486

 

Both sides come out fighting: The argument culture and the press

~Deborah Tannen

 

Tannen suggests that “the way events are reported shapes our thinking about them—and can affect the events themselves. Writing in terms of opposition can actually create the opposition and all that goes with it.” (p.482).

 

 

What effect does the concept of ‘no fight, no story’ have on how we view and engage difference(s)?

 

What is ‘one of the most dangerous effects of the argument culture,’ according to Tannen (p.485)? Do you agree or disagree?  Why?

 

In the concluding section of this piece, what does Tannen suggest we can do?  What do you think of her recommendations?

 

Allen Chapter 2

(Click to view reading in HTML)

Allen discusses three conceptions of power—power over, power with, power to. What does she mean by each of these?  How would you distinguish between them?

 

What is the difference between surface and deep structure power relations?

 

Allen explains that the word “discipline” can be used both as a verb and as an adjective.  How do you understand the concept in each of these senses?

 

What are the “Rules of Right” that Allen describes?

 

How is “power a struggle over meaning”?

 

Allen discusses four conceptions of control— simple, technical, bureaucratic, and concertive. What does she mean by each of these?  How would you distinguish between them?

 

How can identification with the organization serve to support and reinforce particular kinds of control?

 

Allen explains that the concept of hegemony—domination through consent—also relies on resistance. What does she mean by this?  What would this look like in practice?

 

Can you think of examples of resistance to hegemonic power? How can it both challenge and legitimate that power?

 

What is Ideology?

 

Which ideological positions most pervade US society?

 

What is the “Ideology of domination”?  How does this concept normalize hierarchy?

 

How is power communicated through: everyday talk, written texts and documents, micropractices, policies and rules?

 

 

Ore 1-17


What is the rule of hypo-descent?

How are racial classifications culturally defined, according to Ore?

How do these classifications shape and define difference?

According to Ore, what is the value of understanding how difference and inequality are constructed?

What are the four primary elements of thinking critically about these issues that Ore identifies?

What is essentialism, and how is it different from a social constructionist orientation?

What are the key features of social construction theory according to Ore?

Ore describes three stages of social constructionism first developed by Berger and Luckman.  What are they, and how do you understand them to operate?

What constructs categories of difference according to Ore?

Ore gives specific examples of how race/ethnicity, social class, sex and gender, and sexuality are constructed.  How are their constructions similar and/or different from one another? Why use categories of difference at all?

What is a matrix of domination and how does it help us understand the social construction of diference?

Rosenblum & Travis 2-37


What is the difference between essentialist and constructionist orientations to understanding the world according to Rosenblum and Travis?

Rosenblum and Travis argue “few of us have grown up as constructionists.” Does this reflect your experience or not?  Why do you think the authors argue this is a common feature of US society?

What role does Naming play in constructing differences? Can you think of personal examples where difference or similarity has been inscribed in a name? What are they? What reactions, if any did you have to the examples provided by Rosenblum and Travis on pages 6-15 describing processes of naming both individuals and groups?

As Rosenblum and Travis use the term, what does dichotomizing mean? How can it be potentially problematic? Provide examples.

How have different categories of difference been dichotomized historically according to Rosenblum and Travis?

How are constructions of disability similar to and/or different from the other categories of difference Rosenblum and Travis identify?

How is the process of dichotomization related to the production of the “Other?” How does this work in practice? Give examples.

What social rules and norms may be used to sanction those who associate with “Others” according to Rosenblum and Travis?

How does stigma operate to reinforce dichotomies?

Ore 182-204


This reading begins with examples of discrimination and racial profiling targeted at persons of Arab descent or persons perceived to be Arab since September 11th.  What were your reactions to these experiences as you read them?  What factors influence your own personal response. How do the experiences described compare or relate to the targeting or profiling of other groups in the United States in recent history?

What are pretext stops? What impact, both real and perceived, might such stops have both on those being stopped, and on public perceptions of that population?

What is the relationship between one’s “master status” and other statuses one might have?  How does Ore suggest that master status comes to have significance?

What are the different types of privilege and oppression described by Ore?  How do they operate? What examples does she provide? What examples can you think of that illustrate how these systems operate socially?

How do prejudice, discrimination, and institutionalized oppression differ from and relate to one another?

On several occasions, using different examples, Ore states that members of a privileged group benefit from a system of oppression even if individual members of that group do not behave in an oppressive manner. What does she mean by this? Can you think of examples to illustrate how this operates for you personally?

What is heterosexism, and how does it differ from homophobia?

How do social organizations and institutions operate to maintain systems of oppression and privilege?  Give examples.

What is the impact of viewing institutionalized oppression or privilege as “the way things are”?

According to Erica Goode (1999) what is one of the most powerful predictors of health?

What is cultural capital? What is a “hidden curriculum”? How do both operate through the educational system to reproduce and maintain systems of privilege?

How does language operate to reproduce and maintain these systems?

What is meant by the term “rape culture” and how does it function as a form of social control?

R & T 325-351


Why are the twelve Supreme Court cases described in this piece “key” cases, and how have they shaped and defined “difference” in the United States?

Summarize and explain the importance of each of the twelve cases described.

How did the Scott v. Sanford case shape and define “citizenship” in the United States?

What did Amendments XII, XIV, and XV provide for?  How did they serve an equalizing function?  In what ways did they perpetuate and reinforce notions of difference?

What implications did Minor v. Happersett have for the rights of “citizens” to vote? How did this decision function to reify (make natural and “real”) social relationships between men and women?

In what social context did the Plessy v. Ferguson case arise?

How did the decision in Plessy v. Ferguson reify relationships between “black” and “white” people?

What justification was provided in the Plessy v. Ferguson decision for a doctrine of “separate but equal”?

Given what you have read about institutionalized privilege and oppression, what is potentially problematic in the statement in the Plessy v. Ferguson decision that “If the two races are to meet upon terms of social equality, it must be the result of natural affinities, a mutual appreciation of each other’s merits and a voluntary consent of individuals.”?

What does Harlan mean in his dissenting opinion when he argues “…the thin disguise of ‘equal’ accommodations for passengers in railroad coaches will not mislead anyone, nor atone for the wrong this day done.”

What is the difference between a social policy or practice that is enforced de jure versus one that is enforced de facto?

How was Brown v. Board of Education a challenge to the separate but equal doctrine?

What was the differential treatment applied to subjects of China that precipitated the Wo v. Hopkins case?

What does the opinion of the court mean when it says “though the law itself be fair on its face and impartial in appearance, yet, it is applied and administered by public authority with an evil eye and unequal hand, so as practically to make unjust and illegal discriminations between persons in similar circumstances.”?

What are the implications of the Wo v. Hopkins decision for legal application of equal protection under the fourteenth amendment?

How does the decision in Elk v. Wilkins extend and reify decisions made in Scott v. Sanford and Minor v. Happersett? How did this decision reify relationships between Native Americans and “citizens” of the United States?

What does the dissenting opinion contend is problematic about the decision of the court in Elk v. Wilkins?

Why is the fact that Lau v. Nichols was decided not on the basis of the Fourteenth Amendment, but on the 1964 Civil Rights Act significant?

What do Rosenblum and Travis mean when they argue that “Lau [v. Nichols] underscores the idea that equality may not be achieved by treating different categories of people in the same way.”?

In what way did the decision in San Antonio School District v. Rodriguez examine the application of “equal protection” to people and their schools based on financial resources and social class?

What does the court’s decision in San Antonio School District v. Rodriguez do to establish social class as fundamentally different from other “classes” of people? What are some implications of this decision? How does the dissenting opinion differ in its analysis of this case?

What implications did the Bowers v. Hardwick decision have for gay rights? How did this decision reify existing sodomy laws in a way that justified and rationalized a prohibition of homosexual sex? How do critics of this decision argue it is inconsistent with the overturning of other legislation, including legislation prohibiting miscegenation (cohabitation, sexual relations, interbreeding, or marriage involving persons of different races)?

What legal precedent was set in the Regents of the University of California v. Bakke concerning the use of Affirmative Action in Higher Education?

In the dissenting opinion, four justices argue that “unlike discrimination against racial minorities, the use of racial preferences for remedial purposes does not inflict a pervasive injury upon individual whites in the sense that wherever they go or whatever they do there is a significant likelihood that they will be treated as second-class citizens because of their color.”  What does this mean?  What do you think of this statement?  What shapes your own ideas and perceptions about this issue?

Rosenblum and Travis indicate that the Bakke decision was effectively overturned when the Supreme Court refused to hear a case in the Hopwood v. Texas case in which a lower court ruled that Texas could not use race as a criterion in admissions decisions.  This is somewhat misleading since the issue has not been decided at the Supreme Court level, and other cases have either been heard or are pending.

For more current information on the Hopwood case and its implications, you may want to visit http://www.law.utexas.edu/hopwood/

Because this issue is still before the courts in the Grutter v. Bollinger, et al. and Gratz v. Bollinger et al. cases with regard to admissions to the University of Michigan Law school, you may want to review additional information about these cases at http://www.umich.edu/~urel/admissions/overview/

For those interested in this topic, a history of Affirmative Action in Higher Education can be found on-line at http://www.infoplease.com/spot/affirmative1.html

How did the decision in PGA Tour v. Martin shape and define the way that the Americans with Disabilities Act is interpreted and enforced?

In each of these cases, how does the decision of the court reflect the changing social context in which the decision is rendered?

What are some of the critical social issues either currently before the court or that you deem likely to come before the Supreme Court in the coming years?

How do court decisions both reflect and shape social values, norms, and policies?

Allen Ch. 3

How would you answer Allen’s questions following the opening scenario: “Why do you think I was upset when she did not recognize that I was a woman?  Why do you think employees who realized their error were so apologetic? Do you think they would have been more, or less alarmed if they had mistaken a man for a woman?  Why?”

What is the difference between sex and gender? How is transgender related to both?

What, if anything, was surprising to you in reading about the historical perspectives on sex and gender?

What is the ideology of patriarchy, and how does it operate in US society?

What is hegemonic masculinity?

What are some of the themes of masculinity and femininity cited?  Can you think of others you would add?

How do gender and labor intersect?

What is job re-segregation?

How is English a “patriarchal language”?

How does Joan Acker argue organizations are gendered?

R & T 126


What did you find yourself reacting to most strongly when reading this story?

How do you make sense of these reactions based on what you have learned about social constructions?

R & T 98-108


Why does the author propose a five-sex classification instead of two?

What, does she argue, are the social impacts of a two-sex system?

What did you find most interesting or surprising in your reading?

In the follow-up piece the author wrote ten years later, how does she indicate her own understanding has shifted?

Why does she now suggest that even a five-sex system is inadequate?

Ore 99-106


Ore argues “gender is so pervasive that in our society we assume it is bred into our genes.” 9p.99) How and why is this the case?  What does this look like in practice?

Identify three examples of how you “do gender” on a daily basis.

How does a sex category become a gender status?

Ore says “the process of gendering and its outcome are legitimated by religion, law, science, and the society’s entire set of values.” (p.101). What are some examples of this?

Ore describes several ways in which work done by non-dominant groups is less valued than that done by dominant groups.  How is this reproduced? Can you think of some examples?

How is the “gendered social order” upheld?

Ore 114-118


What is your understanding of “transgender” after reading this piece?

How is it similar to or different from intersex?

Boswell argues “therapists today acknowledge that androgyny is a healthier gender model for self-actualization than either of the binary genders.” What is your reaction to this statement?  Why?

Boswell also claims, “if moist people were more honest about it they would probably find themselves somewhere in the middle of the bell-shaped curve of gender distribution rather than at the Rambo/bimbo extreme.” How do you react to this statement?  What about this statement is different from that above?

What is the “tyranny of passing”? How is it reproduced and enforced?

How does Boswell se transgender as a “bridge”?

Allen Ch. 4

Answer Allen’s questions: What is your race?  How do you know?  When and how did you learn your racial classification?  Do you remember?

Allen says “The concept of black pride was an empowering force against internalized oppression.” What does she mean by this?

How do “the sociohistorical-political contexts in which the terms were used” shape the appropriateness and acceptability of different terms to designate race to different people?

How are language matters related to race?

What distinguishes race from ethnicity?

What are some of the reasons why race matters that you find to be most compelling?
Allen says “Numerous sources socialize us about our own racial classification as well as how to classify others.” What are some examples of this from your own experience?
What are some examples of ways that racism persists in contemporary society?
How has science been used to support racial ideologies?
What is racial formation?
A recent statement by the American Anthropological Association states “The ‘racial’ worldview was invented to assign some groups to perpetual low status, while others were permitted access to privilege, power, and wealth. . . Given what we know about the capacity of normal humans to achieve and function within any culture, we conclude that present-day inequalities between so-called ‘racial’ groups are not consequences of their biological inheritance but products of historical and contemporary social, economic, educational, and political circumstances.” What implications does this have for your understanding of race? Given this, why does race still matter?

What is the ideology of white supremacy? How is it institutionalized in US culture?

How was the “melting pot” assimilationist model premised on whiteness?

How do you understand the term “racism”?

How were and are racial differences reproduced through the labor market?

What was the rationale for creating affirmative action policies?

How do the media help shape our views about race?

How is race communicated organizationally?

What is white privilege and how does it operate?

R & T 92-97


How is whiteness an “unmarked” cultural category?

How do questions of racial, national, and cultural belonging leak into one another?

Frankenberg states that for many of the white women she interviewed “being white felt like being cultureless.” What does this mean?  How does this measure up to your own experience or to your experience with people who identify as white?

What dilemmas are created by a cultural positioning that resists definition?

One of Frankenberg’s interviewees sees whites as “nondefined definers of other people.” What does this mean? What are the implications of this for US society?

Frankenberg asserts that there is “a double edged sword of a color- and power- evasive repertoire, apparently valorizing cultural difference by doing so in a way that leaves racial and cultural hierarchies intact.” Can you think of examples of how this works?

How does whiteness intersect with class issues?

Frankenberg asserts “rather than feeling “cultureless,” white[s] need to become conscious of the histories and specificities of our cultural positions, and of the political, economic, and creative fusions that form all cultures.” Do you agree?  What is important about this approach?

R & T 254-259


What distinction does the author make between being born white and being bred white?

What are some of the examples given of how children learn to be white?

How does the author argue that this construction of a privileged identity comes at a cost?

What is the cost of whiteness?

What does a belief in biological whiteness make invisible?

How does whiteness enable particular class systems and relationships to operate according to the author?

What is “survivor shame” according to the author?

R & T 263-270


What is “the box” referred to by the authors?  What function does it serve? How is this box symbolic of race relations?

What does the author imply is meant when white parent move out of mixed neighborhoods to find “a nice place to raise kids”?

What are some of the examples given of how racially segregated neighborhoods perpetuate themselves?

What point is the author making in describing the racially segregated Hernando High School as perhaps “the most honest high school in America”?

How do students at America’s high schools learn to “act their color” according to the author?

How can social stigmas reproduce class divisions along the lines of race?

How is a “culture of low expectations” produced?

What is racial tracking?

Ore 28-40


Why does Ore say that ethnicity is optional for Whites only?

What are some examples of “optional ethnicity”?

What does it mean to “pass” as white?

What is the “ethnic miracle” described by the author?

Why, does the author argue, that some whites selectively identify with some but not all of their heritage?

What is a symbolic ethnicity?

What is a hyphenated identity?

What is the cost associated with symbolic ethnicity for society? How does it impact non-whites whose ethnicities are not “optional” in the US?

What is made invisible when the stories of white success are told in terms of individual triumph over adversity?

How do college campuses serve as a site where some of these issues become visible to children of different racial backgrounds?

What does the author mean by the statement “like capitalism, the invisible hand of pluralism does not do well when power relations and externalities are ignored”?

R&T 420-435


Despite decreases in certain kinds of inequality in the US workforce since the 1960s, how do the authors argue that sex, race, and ethnic inequality persist?

The authors state that “job segregation is the linchpin of workplace inequality because the relegation of different groups to different kinds of work both facilitates and legitimates unequal treatment.”  What do they mean by this?  Do you agree or disagree?  Why or why not?

What do the terms “glass ceiling” and “sticky floor” mean with regard to hierarchical segregation in the workplace?

How do “supply-side” explanations serve to justify and rationalize sex and race segregation in the workplace?  What factors are overlooked or ignored from this perspective?

How does structural discrimination operate?

Allen Chapter 5


How does Allen argue attitudes toward class vary according to sociohistorical context?

What are some examples of the ways in which quality of life varies according to socioeconomic status according to Allen?

How does social class affect the political system?

How do race and gender intersect with class?

How can we understand power from a class perspective?

What is the difference between economic, social, and cultural capital?  How do they interact to produce socioeconomic class?

Allen argues that the “’white trash’ stereotype blames the poor for being poor, and it helps to solidify for middle and upper class whites a sense of cultural and intellectual superiority.” How does this operate socially?  Can you think of examples?

How do the “myth of meritocracy” and “culture of poverty ideology” support and reinforce a belief that success is earned through hard work?

How does “the experience of class occurs primarily through communication” ?

What are some examples of media portrayals of class?  How do they shape and define class relationships and values?

How does “the educational system replicates the class structure and corporate system of capitalist societies”?
What is the “correspondence principle”?

Complete the “The Level Playing Field” exercise.  What is your score?  How do you feel about your score relative to the lowest and highest possible scores?  How do you think your life would have been different if your score had been lower or higher?

Ore 69-80


How does “looking at wealth help solve the riddle of seeming black progress alongside economic deterioration?”

How did the unfulfilled promise of land to the freed slaves shape the contemporary economic landscape?

What impact did FHA lending laws have on protecting the white suburb and creating the black ghetto?

How have the FHA’s actions had a lasting impact on the wealth portfolios of black Americans?

How does contemporary bias in lending continue to reproduce this disparity?

How do each of these issues contribute to structural reproduction of inequality?

What impacts does the disparity in wealth distribution have on Black and White Americans?

Ore 90-95


How has the growth in household debt helped keep the economy growing despite wage stagnation at home and economic turmoil abroad…?

How has this produced an un-sustainable growth in debt?

What are some of the inequities reproduced by a growing wage gap?

How do these authors understand and represent the racial wealth gap?

R&T 398-409


What is the “possessive investment in whiteness”?

How did policies of the early 1900s “widen the gap between resources available to whites and those available to aggrieved racial communities”?

How do “minority disadvantages craft advantages for others”?

How have “even seemingly race-neutral policies… increased the absolute value of being white”?

Ore 337-342


How are “poor mothers blamed for almost every imaginable economic and social ill under the sun?”

What is the “triple whammy” referred to by the authors?

What are the “real problems” of poverty according to the authors?  How has welfare reform failed to address those underlying issues?

What are the “dead ends” of the welfare reform debate? What solutions are presented “beyond welfare reform”?

How might these changes break the cycle of socialization and create institutional change?

Ore 262-268


Why does the unfairness in America’s schools “never benefit the children of the poor”?

What are some of the rationalizations provided for this inequity?

How does Tunisia’s school’s story capture the experience of children in under-funded schools?  How do these experiences construct and reproduce difference?

Ore 269-278


How does the story of America’s elite boarding schools contrast with those in Anacostia school in the previous chapter?

How are gender roles contrasted and reproduced in these schools?

How do race and class intersect with the way these roles are constructed? Provide some examples.

How do these schools produce and reproduce cultural capital?

Allen Chapter 8

 

How did you react to Allen’s opening story?  Have you ever found yourself in a similar situation?  Why do you think that individuals

 

How do you define sexuality?  How does it differ from, and intersect with gender issues?

 

What new information did you learn in reading about the history of sexuality?  What surprised you?

 

How have understandings of “normal” and “deviant” sexuality changed over the years? 

 

How are notions of sexuality tied to notions of race, class, and religion?

 

How has the emergence of the medical profession shaped ideas about sexuality?

 

What two sexual revolutions occurred within the United States in the 20th century?

 

How do you understand sexual orientation? How are essentialist and constructionist understandings different?

 

How does oppression on the basis of sexual orientation compare to and/or differ from other differences we have explored in class?

 

How do issues of passing impact GLBTQ people?

 

How does sexuality infuse the workplace?

 

What is heteronormativity? How is it manifest in organizations?

 

Ore 136-148

How has the notion of heterosexuality been produced historically?


How has sex and sexuality changed connotation over the years?


How did heterosexual sex emerge as a challenge by “working-class youths, southern blacks, and Greenwich-Village bohemians” to middle-class, white, norms of sexuality?


How did the construction of heterosexuality normalize binaries of gender identity and associated sexual preference?


How does the author argue that heterosexuality gained hegemonic force?


How has heterosexuality come to be challenge and questioned in the last twenty years?

 

Ore 153-169

How are sexual and bisexual identities constructed according to the author?
How does this chapter depict sexual identity as evolving and in flux? How does this fit with your understanding or experience?
What problems does the author pose with linear models of sexual identity development?
How does identity shift according to a sexual landscape according to the author?
How has the sexual landscape itself changed, and how does this affect sexual identity development?
What importance does the author place on changes in the language we use for self-definition? What are some examples?

Spradlin

What are some of the prices paid for “passing” in organizations according to Spradlin?

What are the six strategies Spradlin describes that are often used to “pass” in organizational settings? 

Have you ever engaged in any of these passing strategies with regard to any aspect of your identity?

Spradlin calls her narrative a “perspective on authenticity.” What does she mean by this?

Allen on Spradlin

Having read Allen’s work all semester, and having read the piece by Spradlin, how does this piece further inform your understanding of “passing” and authenticity, and the intersections between dimensions of difference?

R&T 165-174 

What distinguishes “homosexual identity” from “gay identity” according to the authors?

What are some characteristic differences in the development of gay and lesbian identities?

How does your understanding of gender socialization inform your understanding of how sexual identities are produced?

How do the authors distinguish between “relational” and “political” lesbianism?

What may be some characteristic stages of lesbian identity development? How do these relate to increased consciousness around other matters of difference?

How is bisexual identity constructed?  

What forms may a bisexual identity take?

How does adopting either a conflict or a flexibility model of understanding shape how one regards bisexuality?

R & T 273-276

Why does the author argue that anti-gay slurs are on the increase in schools?

How did you react to the author’s statement that “four out of five gay and lesbian students say they don’t know one supportive adult at school.”?

One of the ways in which sexuality may differ from other identity features is that there is no direct or necessary correlation between the sexuality of one’s family of origin and one’s own.  How might this impact the ways in which homosexual or bisexual children learn to “pass”?

What obstacles to change did Justen face when trying to change his school’s, and state’s harassment policies? How does this inform your understanding of the ways in which meanings of difference are institutionally supported?

What did you take away from reading Justen’s story?